Skip to content

Acejem Reviews – Steins;Gate

September 16, 2011

Welcome fellow ladies and gentlemen. I, Acejem will be your host reviewer this time round by reviewing an anime series called Steins;Gate:


Introductory Points

Before I begin reviewing Steins;Gate specifically, allow me to make some comments regarding the quality of anime as of recently. For a while (since midlate 2008 to late 2010), anime has been stagnating. Things were looking grim since the passing of its most recent glory years of 2006-2007 where epics such as Death Note, Code Geass, The Melancholy Of Haruhi Suzumiya, Tengen Toppa Gurren Lagann, Kanon and Clannad alongside some personal favourites including ef tale of memories, Spice and Wolf, Nodame Cantabile, Seirei no Moritibo, Kara no Kyoukai and 5 Centimetres Per Second were available.

Although 2009 to 2010 had some good series such as Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood, Sengoku Basara, Summer Wars, Bakemonogatari, Rainbow and Eve no Jikan, these were much more a rarity, as there was an average of 1, maybe 2 good animes per season during this period.

Fortunately, come 2011, the anime industry is on full recovery delivering blockbusters such as Madoka Magica in the winter season, AnoHana and Tiger and Bunny in the spring season, and Mawaru Penguindrum and Usagi Drop in the current summer season which is close to concluding. Furthermore, the upcoming fall season shows great potential with titles like Fate/Zero, Persona 4 the Animation, Guilty Crown, Mirai Nikki and Last Exile 2 set to air in the near future. It is indeed looking to be the strongest year since 2007.

Within that, Steins;Gate is definitely one of the stronger animes so far in an already strong and fierce competitive year.

What is Steins;Gate?

In a nutshell, Steins;Gate is a science fiction story about time travelling. It is the anime adaptation of the critically acclaimed visual novel of the same name developed by 5p.b. and Nitroplus. It is produced by studio White Fox (previously known for their anime adaptation of Katanagatari), directed by Hamasaki Hiroshi (nothing too notable other than Texhnolyze) and the series composition done by Hanada Jukki (who seemed to have been invovled with a lot of “moe” series such as K-on, Nichijou, Idolmaster and Seitokai no Ichizon, thus Steins;Gate really sticks out as different). It is a 2-cour (2 season length) series that started airing during the spring season (~March-June) and has just recently finished airing earlier this week.

Although set in the same universe as its apparent spiritual predecessor Chaos;Head, the only common relevance between the two is the location the anime is set in, Akihabara. Otherwise, the two series are completely different both in story and in quality as Chaos;Head was a poorly adapted anime. Therefore, it is incomparable to Steins;Gate and a viewer should not be prejudiced just because he/she has watched or played Chaos;Head in the past.

Story/Plot

Normally, the notion of time travelling, alternative universes are looked upon unfavorably or at the very least seen as a somewhat cheap mechanism as it can often cry “Deus Ex Machina”. However, unlike most series which have a time travelling or alternative universe element, these elements itself are the bread and butter of Steins;Gate‘s story and thus does not feel like “Deus Ex Machina” at all.

The story is about a group of friends composing of Rintaro “Okarin” Okabe (the protaganist), Mayuri “Mayushii” Shinna  and Itaru “Daru” Hashida who have invented a customized microwave device capable of sending text messages into the past. One day, Okabe finds a famous researcher by the name of Makise “Christina” Kurisu (the main heroine) dead in a building, sends a text message to the microwave device by mistake, and finds himself in a situation where Kurisu was “revived” and his time reversed back. Following the event, Okabe introduces further “lab members” into his circle including Suzhua Amane and Moeka “Shining Finger” Kiyruu to further discover this phenomenon.

The first half of the series composes mainly of the cast, mainly Okabe, goofing about and experimenting with their new discovery, like the self-proclaimed “Mad Scientist” he is. Okabe hops back and forth between different “world lines” changing something significant each time. Although there are some dramatic moments, it is fairly lighthearted, with plenty of comedy. Some of the comedy will only be understood by people who understand anime terminology, cliches and tropes, whilst others are more general purpose and will be understood by most people. Fortunately, most of the comedy is in the form of dialogue and is “wit-based” rather than in the slapstick nature, thus it is largely entertaining to see the bickering that goes on between the various “lab members”.

In contrast to the first half of the series, the second half is much more “serious business”. Okabe discovers the inevitable truth and dire consequences of time travelling and altering the past. He strives to undo the alterations and bring the world back to equilibrium. But things are not easy for Okabe as he faces many hurdles and challenges along the way, and the audience is treated with many suspenseful and intriguing plot twists along the way. This second half is where Steins;Gate was transformed from a “good” series to an “amazing” one and is easily comparable to the quality in story and plot twists that Madoka Magica brought us two seasons ago.

Its plot is the strongest component of Steins;Gate as the audience is kept on the edge of their seats and are left wondering what will happen next once the second half of the series commences.

Characters

The characters in Steins;Gate are largely entertaining and compliment each other well as a cast.

The character that stands out the most, is our protaganist, Okabe. He possesses two main personas, his comical “Mad Scientist” persona and his “serious business” persona. His mad scientist persona is most prevalent in the first half of the series, though it does appear in small doses in the second half to prevent it from being a complete drama-fest. Nonetheless, it is always humorous and entertaining to see him with this personality, which the following youtube videos represent:


In contrast, his “serious business” persona constitutes most of Okabe’s personality during the second half, to the point where in dire emergencies he does not give a damn whether or not it will cause the outrage of tens of thousands of feminists:

Despite the two extreme polarities in personalities, Okabe is also able to be nice when he needs or wants to. He can also be a romantic, but I will refrain from showing an example of that as it will be a massive spoiler ;). Okabe is very much a multidimensional and entertaining character  is arguably the “best” male character from 2011 so far.

Another highlight character, is Kurisu. Firstly, I would like to personally thank the developers for making her a good “tsundere”. In this day and age the number of Type A/“Kugrie”-style tsunderes which both verbally and physically abuse others (most commonly the loser, pathetic main male character) one moment and then in complete polarity be lovestruck the next, are just as numerous as there are stars in the sky. It was very refreshing to see a tsundere in the personality Kurisu is, and a part of me wonders why more anime if they choose to include a tsundere, don’t do so the way Kurisu is portrayed:


As for some other characters, Daru is quite hilarious with his otaku antics as serves pretty well as a comic relief character, whilst Mayuri is a decent “moe” character as she isn’t a complete airhead or “moeblob” unlike some other “moe” characters like Mikuru (Haruhi Suzumiya), Yui (K-on) or Tsukasa (Lucky Star). The only character I had a problem with was Moeka, as she was portrayed too much as an emotionless girl type – e.g. Yuki (Haruhi Suzuimya) or Rei (Neon Genesis Evangelion).

Animation and Audio

In regards to animation, White Fox did a decent job. Although not spectacular, it is was no where near terrible.

On the audio front, the opening and ending songs used for the series fit in pretty well:


However, though it was not necessarily bad, there were very few BGM tracks that were notable. The only track I could remember having a significant impact was when the original Steins;Gate Visual Novel opening being used as an insert song for one of the latter eps of the series:

Hence, the weakest components of Steins;Gate were definitely on the visual/audio side of things. Nevertheless, they were at the very least above average given today’s standards and a viewer should not be discouraged just because of non-stellar art or soundtrack.

Conclusion

Steins;Gate is an excellent anime and is worthy to be named as one of the top series of 2011 so far. Not only is it consistent in its pacing (many animes have rather poor pacing), it is one of the rarer 2-cour animes that do not contain much filler (if any) and as a result does not waste much in getting its point across. In addition, it can be a proud member of the “doing justice to the original Visual Novel source material” club, as the vast majority of visual novel adaptations are either mediocre or outright terrible. Aside from Key/Kyoto Animation VN adaptations, ef tale of memories, Higurashi, possibly Fate/Stay Night and now Steins;Gate, I cannot think of any other VN adaptations on top my head that did its original source material justice.

Its story is some of the best I have seen in the anime medium and Okabe as the main protagonist was very entertaining and a total delight to watch. It is a must watch for science fiction fans, and is highly recommended for any anime fan regardless of genre preferences.

Overall Rating: 9/10

Suggestions to Steins;Gate: Madoka Magica


Advertisements

From → Anime

8 Comments
  1. Kagayaki permalink

    I got behind on Steins;Gate midway through last season and then never caught back up, but reading this review makes me think I really should get off my ass and go finish this. From what you said, it sounds like I’ll like the plot for the second half better than the first. Thanks for the lack of spoilers 🙂

  2. Triple_R permalink

    Very impressive review, Acejem.

    I’m particularly impressed by the research and YouTube vids that went into this review. I also liked how you put Steins;Gate into the broader context of where the anime industry is currently at, and was recently at.

    I differ slightly with you – I think that you overrate the plot a little bit, but actually underrate the animation quality a little bit. But on the whole, I have no major differences of opinion with you. I would say I agree with at least a good 90% of this review. I would also say that, on the whole, its a 9/10 quality show.

    Again, really great review. I’m looking forward to the next one. 🙂

  3. Nice – I like the format, too. Not quite as down on 08-10 or as high on ’11 as you are, though!

  4. Reckoner permalink

    Nice format. I do think you’re a little hard on the audio aspects of the anime, but you talked about more or less many of the things that I thought were great in this anime. Steins;Gate is definitely so far one of 2011’s best shows.

  5. Archon_Wing permalink

    That was a extensive review; I really liked those clips you linked. 😀

    I would like more talk about the characters, but that’s just me. I also liked how you noted that the first half was sorta necessary to make this not like an excessive drama fest, such as umm… some Key works and certain animes about flowers.:D

  6. Nice review! I enjoyed the anime too and would also give it a similar rating.

  7. Thanks for all the responses everyone. It was encouraging to see more than expected responses :D.

    @Kagayaki: I highly recommend that you finish it. The second half of the series is significantly better plot-wise and kept me on the edge of my seat, much like Madoka Magica 2 seasons beforehand.

    @Triple R: Cheers. The youtube links were a bit of an experiment, but I’m glad it worked out! Perhaps you are right that I have underrated the animation side of things, but with “pretty looking shows” like Hanasaku Iroha, Usagi Drop and Wandering Son this year… perhaps I’ve been spoilt :p.

    @Guardian Enzo: Thnx. I’m relatively new to blogging so I’ll be striving to improve. I’ve been following your blog for a while now but mainly lurker-wise, but I’ll make sure I’ll comment next time :).

    @Reckoner: Perhaps I was ignorant on the audio side of things, but to me wasn’t really pieces of BGM other than the one I linked above that caught my attention. Compared to say Madoka Magica (which I understand is kinda unfair since the OST for that is done by god-tier Yuki Kajiara) it was definitely lacking, and I feel even series like Anohana and Hanasaku Iroha had better use of music (despite Iroha’s emo, whiny, girly’ tracks, it does -somewhat- work for the series).

    @Archon Wing: I’ll make sure I’ll keep up the youtube clips in my future responses :). I wonder what those “certain animes about flowers” you are talking about … ;)?

    @Moevetures: Hey, thanks for stopping by. Btw dude, you should have told me earlier that you had a wordpress site too… some of your posts were pretty hilarious, particularly the fall seasonal preview scribble :p

Trackbacks & Pingbacks

  1. Acejem Reviews – Year in Review (2011) Part 3 « The Reviews of Extraordinary Gentlemen

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: